SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

The Crawfish Boxes

Perceptions vs. Realty: The Astros Defense

We all have subjective interpretations of who a player is. The Astros are the team we follow the closest so our opinion of their players are more spot on than the casual baseball fan. Around the game, certain players have developed reputations that, warranted or not, tend to stick with them for the better part of their careers.

Defensively speaking, the Astros probably aren't thought of as being very good. Our roster is the oldest in baseball, and we have Carlos Lee. That's two big reasons why people may preceive the Astros as being sub par in the field. Let's take a look at the widely held perception of our players are, and how they've actually fared defensively in 2009:

Ivan Rodriguez

Thought of as: Old Man on his last legs.

This season: Good. (RF/G is a statistic that measures put outs and assists per game)

Lance Berkman

Thought of as: Fat Elvis is more nimble than his nickname indicates

This season: Average

Kaz Matsui

Thought of as: Injury prone, doesn't hold his own at second base

This season: Above Average

Geoff Blum

Thought of as: Wait...he still plays? Ed Wade is an idiot.

This season: Excellent

Miguel Tejada

Thought of as: Was written about in Moneyball. Used PED's (probably). Another dumb Wade trade.

This season: Struggles

Carlos Lee

Thought of as: Remember that photo Alyson Footer snapped of Carlos with a Mickey D's bag? That sums it up.

This season: Struggles. But not the worst! Thank you, Dave Duncan's son.

Michael Bourn

Thought of as: Quick as a hiccup!

This season: Very Good

Hunter Pence

Thought of as: Young. Runs sorta funny.

This season: Like a Boss

 

0 recs  |  5 comments

Comments

hate to mention this...

but “reality” is misspelled in the headline.

Miguel Tejada

Started off the season well, and seemed to be continuing his shortstop defense from last year. But sometime around the beginning of May, his defensive performance dropped quite a bit. Not sure why. Hopefully it’s just a blip, and he will improve to something like average or just above average.

Surprising to see Adam Everett’s UZR so low too.

hahaha

omg i love this:

Hunter Pence

Thought of as: Young. Runs sorta funny.

This season: Like a Boss

i LOLd in my silent office.

i wish we could see how keppinger does defensively but that would require starts….. and cooper seems to hate the dude for some unknown reason.

not a statistician

but are these numbers really meaningful, only a quarter of the way thru the season?

depends on what you mean by meaningful.

It does reflect what the players have done so far. And most of the starters have enough chances in the field that you don’t get ridiculous results. I’d say this is similar to looking at a starting hitter’s offensive numbers right now. It doesn’t tell you where he will end up at the end of the year (still plenty of time for performance reversal), but you have enough results that you can tell who is getting off to good starts or bad starts or continung what they were doing last year.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of The Crawfish Boxes to post a comment.