SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

The Crawfish Boxes

Good News About Jeff Bagwell's HOF Chances

Well, thanks to the crack research team at Baseball Reference, we can see every Hall of Fame ballot and voting percentages for players going back to 1936.

Here's the good news: only two players since 1972 have not been elected to the Hall of Fame after reaching at least 50 percent on a ballot. The first was Gil Hodges, who got to 50 percent on his third try at the ballot in 1971 and then fell back below the next year. Hodges spend the next decade vacillating between 50 and 60 percent of the vote before failing to get to 75 percent by his 15th season in 1983.

The other so far is is Jack Morris, who still has two more years on the ballot left and got up to 66.7 percent this season. It looks likely that Morris will get over the hump in the next two years to be elected.

Two more players, Nellie Fox and Jim Bunning, reached 50 percent during that time frame and failed to be elected during their 15 year eligibility. However, both were inducted through the Veteran's Committee eventually.

Does that mean Bagwell is a lock to get in? Not necessarily, but the increase is very encouraging. I know there are plenty of big names becoming eligible next season, but the way the voters are trending, don't expect many votes to be stolen by Barry Bonds and Roger Clemens.

Next year will be just as crucial, with Bagwell needing to see an increase to avoid ping-ponging around like Hodges did. If he gets above 60 percent then, there's a good chance Cooperstown will come calling eventually.

0 recs  |  9 comments

Comments

I'm confident that he'll be voted in.

Not this time next year, but two years from now.

I hope him going in with Biggio appeals to the voters

I think it’s all a matter of who’s on the ballot. With more and more suspects players appearing on the ballot, it will become more about stats than what they did or didn’t do biologically.

Agreed

Its going to be hard to keep some of the confirmed users out of the HOF, such as Bonds and Clemens, and if they can get in why can’t Baggy, who was never found dirty.

Off topic (again)

Stros just signed 3 teens from the DR. 2 pitchers and 1 OFer. The OFer is said to be the best position player left on the market (not sure if that’s saying much), which is nice to hear. Good to know we’re still looking at aquiring talent.

HOF is overrated...

Baggy was my favorite player growing up, and not being in the Hall does nothing to change my love for his style of play.

He was my favorite player too

He was the real reason I became interested in baseball. From his weird batting stance and incredible power, to his crazy flexability to stretch for balls at 1st, he was flat out amazing. I have no doubt he’ll get in but if he doesn’t I wouldn’t think any less of him or his play. I might think less of the HOF though…

Poll

USA Today has a poll as to whether Bagwell has been treated unfairly by HOF voters. Register a vote if you want.

I think I’m having more fun writing my next upcoming post than any one previously. I am enjoying crushing any attempt at explaining why he shouldn’t be in the hall. I voted (A), obviously.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of The Crawfish Boxes to post a comment.